We get this question almost every day in our San Antonio practice: “Should I get dentures or implants?” And honestly? Honestly, there’s no one-size-fits-all here. What worked for your buddy down the street might be a total disaster for you.
After walking a ton of folks through this whole “what should I do about my teeth?” situation, we can tell you—it’s way more personal than just picking A or B. It’s your life, your goals, your tolerance for dental shenanigans. So, yeah, let’s actually break it down together.
What Are Dentures?
Dentures have been around forever—seriously, your grandma’s grandma probably had ‘em. They’re basically fake teeth you pop in and out, sitting on your gums. Sometimes you get that satisfying suction, sometimes you’re gluing those suckers in with adhesive. Pretty straightforward.
The thing about dentures is they get the job done without breaking the bank. If you’re missing a bunch of teeth and the idea of surgery makes you want to run for the hills, dentures could be your jam. The process? Not too crazy. A few trips to the dentist for some molds and fittings, and you’re off to the races.
But here’s what patients don’t always expect: dentures have a learning curve. They can slip when you’re eating or talking, especially in the beginning. We’ve had patients tell us they avoid certain foods because they’re worried about their dentures moving around. And yes, you’ll need to take them out at night and clean them separately.
Your mouth also changes over time. Here’s the catch: your jawbone, the part where your teeth used to live, doesn’t exactly stay put. It slowly shrinks away over time, which means those dentures that fit like a glove today might feel like you’re chewing with a pair of Crocs in a few years. Most folks need a tune-up or brand-new set every 5 to 7 years. Annoying? Yeah, a bit. But it’s just part of the deal.
What Are Dental Implants?
Dental implants work completely differently. So, instead of just chilling on your gums, these bad boys get drilled right into your jawbone. Yeah, I know—sounds kinda hardcore, right? But stick with me.
Picture this: it’s basically a tiny titanium screw taking over for your old tooth root. After a bit, your bone just sort of hugs it tight, locking it down for good. Then we slap a crown on top and boom—it’s basically your old tooth, but maybe even a little tougher.
The process takes longer—usually 3-6 months from start to finish. But here’s what’s cool: most of our patients get temporary teeth the same day we place the implants. You won’t be walking around toothless.
What really gets people excited about implants is how normal they feel. You can eat whatever you want—steak, corn on the cob, apples. No special cleaning routine, no adhesives, no taking them out at night. They’re just there, doing their job.
The other big advantage? They keep your jawbone healthy. When you lose teeth, your jawbone starts shrinking. Implants prevent that from happening, which keeps your face looking fuller and more youthful.
What Are Implant-Supported Dentures?
You know what? Sometimes mixing things up just works better. Take implant-supported dentures, for example. Instead of sticking a fake tooth in every single gap (which, yikes, gets pricey and complicated), you just pop in a few implants in the right spots. Boom—whole new smile anchored down.
Here in San Antonio, we’re all about that All-on-4 life. Four implants, whole row of teeth, done. Way cheaper than going one by one, but you still get that rock-solid, chomp-on-a-steak stability. Honestly, traditional dentures don’t even come close. Ever had one of those things slide around in your mouth at the worst possible moment? Yeah, not fun.
With these guys, you just snap ’em in place. Super secure, but you can still pop them out when it’s time to clean up. Our patients? Most of them are obsessed—they get the confidence of real teeth, minus the stress of fiddling with a mouthful of individual implants. Kinda the best of both worlds, if you ask me.
What Nobody Tells You About Complications
Every dental treatment has risks. Let me be straight with you about what can go wrong.
Denture Complications
With dentures, the biggest issue is fit. Your mouth changes, dentures get loose, you get sore spots. Some people develop infections if they don’t keep things clean or wear their dentures too long. I’ve seen patients have reactions to denture adhesives too.
The other thing? That bone shrinkage I mentioned earlier. It’s real, and it changes how your face looks over time. That’s actually why you see some folks who wear dentures for ages end up with that hollowed, sunken look in their cheeks. It’s not just bad luck—it’s the jaw bone shrinking away.
Dental Implants Complications
Now, implants? They’re awesome, don’t get me wrong. Success rate’s around 95%, which sounds fantastic unless you’re in that unlucky 5%. Sometimes the darn thing just refuses to mesh with your bone, like your body’s being stubborn for no reason. And then you’ve got stuff like infections—peri-implantitis, if you wanna get fancy. Basically, the area around the implant acts up and gets all inflamed.
Surgery isn’t a walk in the park, either. There’s a teeny chance you could hit a nerve or poke into the sinus cavity—yikes, right? That’s why we’re obsessed with 3D scans and planning everything to the last millimeter. I’ve been at this for years, and honestly, these problems are rare, but hey, they’re not unicorns. They do pop up every now and then.
Smokers have way more problems with implants. If you smoke, we need to have a serious conversation about quitting before we do any implant work.
Implants or Dentures – How Do You Actually Decide?
This is where we spend most of our consultation time with patients. There’s a lot to consider.
Your health matters big time. If you’ve got uncontrolled diabetes, take certain medications, or have autoimmune issues, implants might not be the best choice. Sometimes your body just isn’t set up for the healing process implants require.
How much bone you have left makes a difference too. If you’ve been without teeth for years, you might need bone grafting before we can place implants. Some patients are up for that, others prefer to skip the extra procedures and go with dentures.
Age isn’t necessarily a deal-breaker for implants—we’ve done them on 85-year-olds—but it’s worth thinking about your long-term outlook.
Money’s obviously a factor. Be realistic about what you can afford, not just now but over the long haul.
Think about your lifestyle too. Do you travel a lot? Are you super active? Do you do a lot of public speaking? These things might influence which option makes more sense for you.
The Stuff That Really Matters
Here’s what I’ve noticed after doing this for years: the patients who are happiest with their choice are the ones who understood what they were getting into from the beginning.
If you choose dentures, accept that there’s a learning curve. You might need adjustments. You’ll have a different routine for taking care of them. But they’ll get you eating and smiling again without surgery.
If you go with implants, understand that it’s a process. It takes months. There might be some discomfort. But at the end, you’ll have something that works almost exactly like your natural teeth did.
No matter which way you go, you’re leveling up your quality of life—seriously. I’ve actually watched people tear up (the happy kind, not the “just bit into a jalapeño” kind) when they finally get to chow down on their favorite meal again, or crack a smile without worrying someone’s judging their teeth.
So, What’s the Verdict?
Here’s the real talk: there’s no universal “winner” between dentures and implants. It’s all about you—your health, your wallet, your goals, all that jazz.
Plenty of our patients are living their best lives with plain ol’ dentures. Others? You’d have to pry their implants out of their jaws with a crowbar. Point is, you need to know what to expect and have someone in your corner who’ll be honest with you from the jump.
If you’re anywhere near San Antonio and want to hash this out, come see us. We’ll actually listen to what you want, check out what’s going on in there, and help you map out a plan that works for your life, not just some brochure.
And hey, don’t get caught up chasing perfection. Dentures or implants—either one can seriously boost your quality of life. The trick is to just get started and finally get that smile back.
Dentures vs Dental Implants
Complete Comparison Guide for San Antonio Patients
Traditional Dentures
Dental Implants
Investment Comparison
Traditional Dentures
Requires regular adjustments and eventual replacement
Implant-Supported Dentures
Best of both worlds – stability with affordability
Individual Implants
Often lifetime investment with proper care
Key Considerations
Choose Dentures If You…
- Want to avoid surgery
- Need a budget-friendly solution
- Want quick results
- Have health conditions that complicate surgery
- Prefer removable teeth for cleaning
- Are comfortable with regular adjustments
Choose Implants If You…
- Want the most natural feel
- Can invest in long-term solution
- Want to eat without restrictions
- Are in good overall health
- Want to preserve facial structure
- Prefer permanent, fixed teeth
What Affects Your Decision?
Ready to Restore Your Smile?
Every situation is unique. Let our San Antonio team help you choose the best option for your needs, budget, and lifestyle.
Schedule Free Consultation